This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience.

Cookie Settings

Company logo
Rated "Excellent" by our customers

Search articles

Search tips...

Rated "Excellent" by our customers
See our 4,718 reviews on
A snowy background advertising our Christmas Health Food Shop
A banner showing the Scottish flag
A banner showing nuts and seeds

The Great Christmas Bake Off … Festive Fails and How to Salvage Them

Christmas baking is supposed to be all about spreading cheer and deliciousness, but sometimes, things go hilariously wrong. Here's a light-hearted guide to turning those festive fails into unexpected wins:

1. Collapsed Cookies

Did your cookies melt into one giant blob? No worries! Break them apart to create a cookie crumble topping for ice cream or layer them in a dessert parfait.

Layered dessert in glass jar with cookie crumble and whipped cream decorated with rosemary and anise, dark brown background. No bake cheesecake, trifle or pudding.

2. Rock-Hard Fruitcake

If your fruitcake could double as a doorstep or a home defence tool, try cubing it and soaking it in rum or sweet wine to make a boozy, soft trifle base.

raspberry and almond trifle for Christmas

3. Burnt Gingerbread

Did your gingerbread men tan a bit too much? Crush them up and use them as a spicy base for a cheesecake or mix them into homemade ice cream for a festive crunch.

Sad burnt gingerbread cookies

4. Runny Icing 

If your icing is more like a glaze, use it as a drizzle over pancakes or waffles for a Christmas morning treat.

Decadent Stack of Pumpkin Spice Pancakes dripping with Sweet Syrup on a rustic gray wood background

5. Flat Pannetone

Panettone didn't rise to the occasion? Cube it and toast the pieces to make a luxurious bread pudding with an extra dose of custard.

Homemade Panettone. Tradidional Italian Christmas Cake

6. Over-Spiced Pumpkin Pie

Got too generious with the clove or nutmeg? Balance it out by serving slices of your pumpkin pie with a dollop of whipped cream or vanilla ice cream to mellow the flavours.

Homemade Pumpkin Pie for Thanksgiving Ready to Eat

Whatever the kitchen disaster, you can always turn things around with a pinch of creativity and a spoonful of laughter. Remember, the best holiday memories often come from those imperfect moments shared with loves ones.

So, as you tie your apron strings and preheat the ovens, here's wishing you a season filled with warmth, laughter, and plenty of delicious "mistakes" that lead to new traditions. May your holiday be as joyfully unexpected as a well-timed snowfall on Christmas morning. Happy baking!